CONCESSIONS BY COLLEGES TO ANTI-ISRAEL PROTESTERS
Facilitate a meeting with the chair of the Corporation Committee on Shareholder Responsibility and other university officials to address questions about the endowment
Meet, along with the dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, to hear students’s perspectives on academic matters related to the Middle East
Retract suspensions of students participating in the encampment and expedite reinstatement proceedings once the encampment was removed (note: the protest encampment was expanded to the graduation commencement lawn, with Garber warning that repercussions would become more consequential as graduation approached. In the end, Harvard prevented 15 students from graduating.)
Meet with members of the Harvard management company regarding disclosure about investments with Israeli companies and divestment from them
Discuss the establishment of a Center for Palestine Studies at Harvard
Permit protests and gatherings at Deering Meadow (Northwestern’s traditional gathering place) through June 1, the final day of classes for the spring quarter. However, only Northwestern students, faculty and staff will be allowed in the demonstration area, unless otherwise authorized by the university
Allow the Northwestern Divestment Coalition (i.e. the encampment organizers) to leave one “aid tent” on Deering Meadow
Allow students to use (approved) devices to project or amplify sound
Advise employers not to rescind job offers for students “engaging in speech protected by the First Amendment”
Support two visiting Palestinian faculty per year for two years
Pay the cost of attendance for five Palestinian undergraduates to attend Northwestern
Fundraise for the above two concessions “beyond this current agreement”
Provide immediate temporary space for Middle East and North African (MENA) and Muslim students to gather
Provide and renovate a house for MENA and Muslim students as soon as possible, with the expectation that it will be completed by 2026
Engage students in a process to ensure “additional support” for Jewish and Muslim students
Include “broad input” from students on university dining services, including residential and retail vendors on campus, regarding Israeli-made products
Provide a conduit for students to engage with the Investment Committee of the Board of Trustees
Re-establish an Advisory Committee on Investment Responsibility in the fall, which will include students, faculty and staff
Commit to answering questions from any “internal stakeholder” about specific university holdings held currently or within the last quarter to “the best of its knowledge or to the extent legally possible” within 30 days.
Accept at least 10 displaced Palestinian students to study and finish their education at Rutgers on scholarship
Provide Palestinian and Arab students with an Arab cultural center on each of Rutgers’ campuses
Establish a “memorandum of understanding” for a long-term educational and collaboration partnership with Ramallah’s Hamas-supporting Birzeit University, in accordance with the precedent set by William Paterson University
Use the words “Palestine” and “Palestinians” (versus the words “Middle East,” “Gaza region,” etc.) in relation to the Israel-Hamas conflict and release a statement from the Office of the President acknowledging the “ongoing genocide against Palestinians, its impact on the Palestinian community at our university, and advocating for a ceasefire.”
Hire senior administrators with “cultural competency and knowledge about Arabs, Palestinians, Muslims, anti-Palestinian racism, and Islamophobia.”
Hire additional professors specializing in Palestine studies and Middle East studies, establish a center for Palestine studies and “establish a path” to a Middle East studies department
Display the flags of “occupied peoples — including but not limited to Palestinians, Kurds, and Kashmiris —” in all areas displaying international flags across the Rutgers campuses.
Provide “full amnesty” for all students, student groups, faculty and staff penalized for their anti-Israel protest activity
The university agreed to
Review all complaints about existing global exchange and internship programs, and review new and future programs to ensure they comply with the university’s anti-discrimination policy
Cease participation in programs that violate the above policy
Establish a transparent process by December 2024 for the ongoing review of complaints about violations of the above policy
According to Los Angeles Times reporter Teresa Watanabe, UC Berkeley’s chancellor Carol Christ said she:
Backs a ceasefire in Gaza
Stated that support for the plight of Palestinians "should not be conflated with hatred or antisemitism."
Intends to instruct the university to investigate whether campus investments align with the values of human rights, equality and abhorrence of war
Agreed to
Hold a vote by its Board of Trustees on divesting from Israel
Invite a group of five students to meet with five members of the Brown Corporation (while the latter are in town for their meeting in May)
Treat student activists’ commitment to end the encampment as “a favorable mitigating factor” in disciplinary matters
Agreed to
Call for a cease-fire in Gaza
Refrain from punishing students involved with the encampment
Join calls for a cease-fire in Gaza
Agreed to
“Facilitate access to relevant decision makers” by July
Treat student activists’ commitment to end the encampment as “a favorable mitigating factor” in disciplinary matters
President Mike Lee promised
To institute an academic boycott of Israel (note: Lee was subsequently put on leave by California State University chancellor Mildred Garcia)
Agreed to
Grant amnesty in university disciplinary measures related to the encampments
Facilitate a meeting between students and trustees or investment managers regarding investments in Israeli companies
Agreed to
“Prioritize review” of a military divestment proposal
Endeavor to recruit and support Palestinian students and scholars who have lost educational opportunities since Oct. 7
Support student-led fundraising efforts “around refugees”
Promised a “timely review” of the protesters’ divestment issues, using the university’s “existing process.”
Promised that the university’s Board of Trustees would vote on divestment
Reached an agreement under which the university Board of Trustees’ investment committee will hear a divestment proposal from students in September and hold a vote
Agreed to a campus-wide statement in which President John Carmichael said he was “horrified and grief-stricken by the violence and suffering being inflicted due to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict”